One of the most shocking statements I have ever heard made about Islam, and any other religion, is that they they all teach pretty much the same thing. I was utterly shocked when a gutsy Muslim Apologist even went as far as using the word "repentance" to describe how salvation is obtained in Islam. He kept going even claiming that it was similar to the Christian experience. I was completely outraged, how could they even attempt to make such a claim. It's been a few years since hearing those words, and I now know why he had the audacity to claim such a similarity.
At the heart of Christianity is the belief that the historical man Jesus Christ, the living Son of God, resurrected from the grave, and ascended into heaven, from which he poured out his Holy Spirit into our souls, when we place our faith in him. The tenses change on purpose, because the Holy Spirit has been poured out upon people, and continues to be poured out into souls today, for everyone who places their faith in Jesus. Even a little incsy wincsy bit of faith, is precious in God's sight, and he will not crush it, but protect it in his majestic hands. When you believe and the Holy Spirit comes to live within you, things start to change at home. All of a sudden you think differently, like different things, and don't like other things you liked before.
What the Church in many regards has failed to explain is what happens when you believe. How does it all work? What if I was grew up in the Church, and I can't remember not believing? (A future piece will be written to address that.)
These are legitimate questions, that we don't talk about, or when the Church does, its often the wrong message people are hearing. Sometimes the only message people hear from the Church is "turn to God, dress modestly, don't do drugs, and stop sleeping around." That is not the gospel, or the good news about Christianity. In fact, that's not good news at all. Good news is that God loves me so much, he took upon flesh, came to Earth as the man Jesus Christ, died in my place, for my sins, gives himself to me as a free gift, changes my heart, my mind, and desires enabling me to follow him, with such intensity that I am called a "new person". That's good news. Following a bunch of rules I can't follow in the first place is NOT GOOD NEWS.
The problem is that a lot of churches still tell people exactly that: to devote yourself to God and follow a bunch of rules. That is not GOOD NEWS. That's religion, and it doesn't belong in the Church. But the problem goes much deeper than that. The problem becomes exponentially deeper when words like "repentance" are thrown around and never explained. So much so that some MUSLIMS think that they have obtained the Christian experience. Then Christians get judged harshly because we don't "appear" to be as devoted to God, as they, or any other religion is.
First and foremost, "repentance" as used in the Christian sense does not mean "devoting yourself to God and following rules". Externally it may have that appearance but the Greek word used the New Testament for repentance, metanoia, literally means "to change your mind". That is exactly the meaning intended. It means to change your mind about who God is, how to worship him, its a casting off of all self-reliance, and putting all your trust in God.
This is why Paul can say statements like "testifying both to Jews and to Greeks of repentance toward God and of faith in our Lord Jesus Christ." as his central message he has been preaching in Acts 20:21.
And then again in Romans 8:6 "For to set the mind on the flesh is death, but to set the mind on the Spirit is life and peace." Notice here that it is the mind that is being set on one thing or another. Repentance toward God involves setting your mind on his Spirit, the Holy Spirit.
Notice another thing that is different about Christian repentance, is that the object of your worship is real, its Jesus Christ. The man who proved he was God when he resurrected from the dead about 2000 years ago and the whole world has not been the same ever since.
There is two main problems with the religious view of repentance, besides it being an unauthentic meaning of the word as used in Scripture.
- One, if your devotion is not to the real God, it has no power to offer you, and in fact, can do zilch for you, besides ticking the real God off. That's why Jesus Christ is the object of Christian repentance, we turn from our old way of thinking, to a new way of thinking looking to Jesus Christ, the real God.
- Second, your devotion to God will never be good enough to satisfy God's requirements. Why? Because we are a jacked up people, humans are flawed. God says "your righteousness is like dirty menstrual rags to me" paraphrasing Isaiah 64:6. That's why you always here stuff like, religious people are hypocrites. Why? Because they are. You can't be perfect, and God demands perfection, because he is perfect.
The good news is that you don't have to be perfect. God figured out a way to be perfect for you, by being the perfect sacrifice on the cross, where all of his righteousness comes to you when you trust in him. Then the perfect comes inside of you, and gives you power to live a new life, that you otherwise could not have lived. We call this "regeneration" and it is different from repentance. Regeneration is what happens before and after repentance. Its God at work inside of you making you a new person from the inside out by changing your heart, and desires. The difference is that you can have a false repentance, without regeneration. Without regeneration, your repentance just looks like religion, because you have no new heart. You are still the evil, wicked, proud, self-righteous human. Regeneration is what happened when all of a sudden you don't like what you used to do, because you think it is wrong now. Regeneration is when you all of a sudden want to read the Bible in one day, because if God has spoken, you want to hear what he has to say.
Paul in his letter to the Philippians says "work out your salvation with fear and trembling; for it is God who is at work in you, both to will and to work for His good pleasure."
Paul here shows that regeneration happens both before and after repentance. Regeneration through repentance produces the following results inside of us "But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control".
Regeneration is the God part of the "new you" in the Christian experience, and repentance is your role in the "new you" in the Christian experience. Finally lets not forget that false repentance excludes God's grace in our salvation. None of us deserves salvation, but God gave it to us as a free gift.
"At one time we too were foolish, disobedient, deceived and enslaved by all kinds of passions and pleasures. We lived in malice and envy, being hated and hating one another. But when the goodness and loving kindness of God our Savior appeared, he saved us, not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit, whom he poured out on us richly through Jesus Christ our Savior, so that being justified by his grace we might become heirs according to the hope of eternal life." (Titus 3:3-7)
Concluding thoughts:
Repentance is also not "self-abnegation" as described my Mark Oppenheimer in the Wall Street Journal. Christian repentance, is preceded by regeneration, so that you have the power to deny your weaker desires, because you have a greater desire for the pure, the perfect, and truth. Yes your "self" needs to be denied, but you can't do that yourself, or you get something stupid called religion. It is by going out to God. Christian self-denial is through "you" going to Jesus, its not by punching a wall has hard as you can, or by "not eating watermelons, because you can't find evidence the prophet Mohammed ate watermelons," which is what one Sufi Muslim did.


